Best Medicare Health Insurance Plans

Bartholomew County, Indiana

The best Medicare plan quality rankings evaluate 34 Medicare Advantage plans and 23 Part D prescription drug plans available in Bartholomew county, Indiana.

The overall best Medicare plan quality scoring is based on government five star ratings covering several different Medicare Advantage health plan areas, including customer service, member experience, managing member health conditions, and member complaints. For Medicare plans which include Part D prescription drug coverage, the overall government ratings also cover drug related areas including drug plan customer service, member experience, drug safety, and drug pricing.

Medicare Advantage Plans with Part D - Prescription Drug Coverage

There are 25 Medicare Advantage plans with Part D available in Bartholomew county, Indiana. Government five star ratings for overall quality show that 4 of these plans are in our top tier, having a score of 4.5 or above. There are 17 plans in our middle tier with a quality score of 4.0 or 3.5, and there are 0 plans in our bottom tier with a quality score of 3.0 or below. 4 plans are considered new plans and do not have quality ratings yet.

Top Tier - Best Plans

Insurance Carrier Plan Name
Aetna Medicare
 4.5
UnitedHealthcare
 4.5
Aetna Medicare
 4.5
Indiana University Health Plans
 4.5

Middle Tier - Average Plans

Insurance Carrier Plan Name
Humana
 4.0
Humana
 4.0
Humana
 4.0
UnitedHealthcare
 4.0
Humana
 4.0
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield
 4.0
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield
 4.0
UnitedHealthcare
 4.0
Humana
 4.0
Humana
 4.0
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield
 4.0
Humana
 4.0
Wellcare by Allwell
 3.5
Wellcare by Allwell
 3.5
Anthem HealthKeepers
 3.5
Anthem HealthKeepers
 3.5
Wellcare by Allwell
 3.5

Bottom Tier - Below Average Plans

There are no plans for this Tier

New Plans Without Star Ratings

Insurance Carrier Plan Name
Wellcare by Allwell
No Rating
MyTruAdvantage
No Rating
MyTruAdvantage
No Rating
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield
No Rating

Medicare Advantage Plans - No Drug Coverage

There are 9 Medicare Advantage plans with no drug coverage available in Bartholomew county, Indiana. Government five star ratings for overall quality show that 2 of these plans are in our top tier, having a score of 4.5 or above. There are 3 plans in our middle tier with a quality score of 4.0 or 3.5, and there are 2 plans in our bottom tier with a quality score of 3.0 or below. 2 plans are considered new plans and do not have quality ratings yet.

Top Tier - Best Plans

Insurance Carrier Plan Name
Indiana University Health Plans
 4.5
Aetna Medicare
 4.5

Middle Tier - Average Plans

Insurance Carrier Plan Name
Humana
 4.0
Humana
 4.0
UnitedHealthcare
 4.0

Bottom Tier - Below Average Plans

Insurance Carrier Plan Name
Lasso Healthcare
 2.0
Lasso Healthcare
 2.0

New Plans Without Star Ratings

Insurance Carrier Plan Name
Wellcare by Allwell
No Rating
Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield
No Rating

Medicare Part D - Prescription Drug Plans

There are 23 Medicare Part D prescription drug plans available in Bartholomew county, Indiana. Government five star ratings for overall quality show that 0 of these plans are in our top tier, having a score of 4.5 or above. There are 19 plans in our middle tier with a quality score of 4.0 or 3.5, and there are 4 plans in our bottom tier with a quality score of 3.0 or below. 0 plans are considered new plans and do not have quality ratings yet.

Top Tier - Best Plans

There are no plans for this Tier

Middle Tier - Average Plans

Insurance Carrier Plan Name
Humana
 4.0
UnitedHealthcare
 4.0
UnitedHealthcare
 4.0
Humana
 4.0
Anthem / Anthem or Blue KC in Missouri
 4.0
Anthem / Anthem or Blue KC in Missouri
 4.0
Humana
 4.0
Mutual of Omaha Rx
 3.5
Mutual of Omaha Rx
 3.5
UnitedHealthcare
 3.5
Aetna Medicare
 3.5
Cigna
 3.5
Cigna
 3.5
Wellcare
 3.5
Aetna Medicare
 3.5
Wellcare
 3.5
Aetna Medicare
 3.5
Wellcare
 3.5
Cigna
 3.5

Bottom Tier - Below Average Plans

Insurance Carrier Plan Name
Elixir Insurance
 3.0
Elixir Insurance
 3.0
Clear Spring Health
 2.0
Clear Spring Health
 2.0

New Plans Without Star Ratings

There are no plans for this Tier