Best Medicare Health Insurance Plans

Hillsborough County, Florida

The best Medicare plan quality rankings evaluate 50 Medicare Advantage plans and 28 Part D prescription drug plans available in Hillsborough county, Florida.

The overall best Medicare plan quality scoring is based on government five star ratings covering several different Medicare Advantage health plan areas, including customer service, member experience, managing member health conditions, and member complaints. For Medicare plans which include Part D prescription drug coverage, the overall government ratings also cover drug related areas including drug plan customer service, member experience, drug safety, and drug pricing.

Medicare Advantage Plans with Part D - Prescription Drug Coverage

There are 43 Medicare Advantage plans with Part D available in Hillsborough county, Florida. Government five star ratings for overall quality show that 13 of these plans are in our top tier, having a score of 4.5 or above. There are 21 plans in our middle tier with a quality score of 4.0 or 3.5, and there are 0 plans in our bottom tier with a quality score of 3.0 or below. 9 plans are considered new plans and do not have quality ratings yet.

Top Tier - Best Plans

Insurance Carrier	Plan Name / Quality Rating	Quality Rating
Cigna	Cigna Preferred Savings Medicare (HMO) 5.0	5.0
CarePlus Health Plans, Inc.	CareOne PLUS (HMO) 5.0	5.0
Cigna	Cigna Primary Medicare (HMO) 5.0	5.0
Cigna	Cigna Preferred Medicare (HMO) 5.0	5.0
CarePlus Health Plans, Inc.	CareOne PLATINUM (HMO) 5.0	5.0
CarePlus Health Plans, Inc.	CareFree (HMO) 5.0	5.0
Florida Blue HMO	BlueMedicare Premier (HMO) 4.5	4.5
Optimum HealthCare, Inc.	Optimum Platinum Plan (HMO) 4.5	4.5
Optimum HealthCare, Inc.	Optimum Gold Rewards Plan (HMO) 4.5	4.5
Humana	Humana Gold Plus H1036-265 (HMO) 4.5	4.5
Florida Blue HMO	BlueMedicare Saver (HMO) 4.5	4.5
Florida Blue HMO	BlueMedicare Classic (HMO) 4.5	4.5
Humana	Humana Gold Plus H1036-025 (HMO) 4.5	4.5

Middle Tier - Average Plans

Insurance Carrier	Plan Name / Quality Rating	Quality Rating
WellCare	WellCare Dividend Prime (HMO) 4.0	4.0
Aetna Medicare	Aetna Medicare Choice (HMO-POS) 4.0	4.0
Aetna Medicare	Aetna Medicare Premier (PPO) 4.0	4.0
Aetna Medicare	Aetna Medicare Select (HMO) 4.0	4.0
Humana	HumanaChoice Florida H5216-072 (PPO) 4.0	4.0
Simply Healthcare Plans, Inc.	Simply Select (HMO) 4.0	4.0
Aetna Medicare	Aetna Medicare Premier Plus (PPO) 4.0	4.0
Simply Healthcare Plans, Inc.	Simply More (HMO) 4.0	4.0
WellCare	WellCare Elite (HMO) 4.0	4.0
Ultimate Health Plans	Premier Plus by Ultimate (HMO) 4.0	4.0
Freedom Health, Inc.	Freedom Medicare Plan Rx (HMO) 4.0	4.0
Ultimate Health Plans	Premier by Ultimate (HMO) 4.0	4.0
UnitedHealthcare	AARP Medicare Advantage (HMO-POS) 3.5	3.5
UnitedHealthcare	AARP Medicare Advantage Choice Plan 2 (Regional PPO) 3.5	3.5
UnitedHealthcare	AARP Medicare Advantage Focus (HMO-POS) 3.5	3.5
UnitedHealthcare	AARP Medicare Advantage Choice (PPO) 3.5	3.5
Florida Blue	BlueMedicare Value (PPO) 3.5	3.5
Humana	HumanaChoice R5826-074 (Regional PPO) 3.5	3.5
Florida Blue	BlueMedicare Choice (Regional PPO) 3.5	3.5
Humana	HumanaChoice R5826-005 (Regional PPO) 3.5	3.5
Florida Blue	BlueMedicare Select (PPO) 3.5	3.5

Bottom Tier - Below Average Plans

There are no plans for this Tier

New Plans Without Star Ratings

Insurance Carrier	Plan Name / Quality Rating	Quality Rating
Devoted Health	Devoted Health Essentials Greater Tampa Bay (HMO) No Rating	No Rating
BayCare Health Plans	BayCarePlus Complete (HMO) No Rating	No Rating
WellCare	WellCare Premier (PPO) No Rating	No Rating
BayCare Health Plans	BayCarePlus Signature (HMO) No Rating	No Rating
Solis Health Plans	SOLIS SPF 009 (HMO) No Rating	No Rating
Devoted Health	Devoted Health Prime Greater Tampa Bay (HMO) No Rating	No Rating
BayCare Health Plans	BayCarePlus Rewards (HMO) No Rating	No Rating
WellCare	WellCare Prime (PPO) No Rating	No Rating
Devoted Health	Devoted Health Core Greater Tampa Bay (HMO) No Rating	No Rating

Medicare Advantage Plans - No Drug Coverage

There are 7 Medicare Advantage plans with no drug coverage available in Hillsborough county, Florida. Government five star ratings for overall quality show that 1 of these plans are in our top tier, having a score of 4.5 or above. There are 4 plans in our middle tier with a quality score of 4.0 or 3.5, and there are 0 plans in our bottom tier with a quality score of 3.0 or below. 2 plans are considered new plans and do not have quality ratings yet.

Top Tier - Best Plans

Insurance Carrier	Plan Name / Quality Rating	Quality Rating
Humana	Humana Honor (HMO) 4.5	4.5

Middle Tier - Average Plans

Insurance Carrier	Plan Name / Quality Rating	Quality Rating
Aetna Medicare	Aetna Medicare Eagle (PPO) 4.0	4.0
Freedom Health, Inc.	Freedom Savings Plan (HMO) 4.0	4.0
UnitedHealthcare	AARP Medicare Advantage Patriot (Regional PPO) 3.5	3.5
Humana	HumanaChoice R5826-018 (Regional PPO) 3.5	3.5

Bottom Tier - Below Average Plans

There are no plans for this Tier

New Plans Without Star Ratings

Insurance Carrier	Plan Name / Quality Rating	Quality Rating
Lasso Healthcare	Lasso Healthcare Growth Plus (MSA) No Rating	No Rating
Lasso Healthcare	Lasso Healthcare Growth (MSA) No Rating	No Rating

Medicare Part D - Prescription Drug Plans

There are 28 Medicare Part D prescription drug plans available in Hillsborough county, Florida. Government five star ratings for overall quality show that 0 of these plans are in our top tier, having a score of 4.5 or above. There are 22 plans in our middle tier with a quality score of 4.0 or 3.5, and there are 4 plans in our bottom tier with a quality score of 3.0 or below. 2 plans are considered new plans and do not have quality ratings yet.

Top Tier - Best Plans

There are no plans for this Tier

Middle Tier - Average Plans

Insurance Carrier	Plan Name / Quality Rating	Quality Rating
WellCare	WellCare Value Script (PDP) 4.0	4.0
WellCare	WellCare Classic (PDP) 4.0	4.0
WellCare	WellCare Wellness Rx (PDP) 4.0	4.0
Humana	Humana Basic Rx Plan (PDP) 3.5	3.5
Express Scripts Medicare	Express Scripts Medicare - Value (PDP) 3.5	3.5
Aetna Medicare	SilverScript SmartRx (PDP) 3.5	3.5
UnitedHealthcare	AARP MedicareRx Preferred (PDP) 3.5	3.5
Express Scripts Medicare	Express Scripts Medicare - Choice (PDP) 3.5	3.5
Humana	Humana Premier Rx Plan (PDP) 3.5	3.5
WellCare	WellCare Medicare Rx Value Plus (PDP) 3.5	3.5
Aetna Medicare	SilverScript Plus (PDP) 3.5	3.5
Cigna	Cigna Secure-Extra Rx (PDP) 3.5	3.5
UnitedHealthcare	AARP MedicareRx Saver Plus (PDP) 3.5	3.5
Humana	Humana Walmart Value Rx Plan (PDP) 3.5	3.5
Express Scripts Medicare	Express Scripts Medicare - Saver (PDP) 3.5	3.5
Aetna Medicare	SilverScript Choice (PDP) 3.5	3.5
Elixir Insurance	Elixir RxPlus (PDP) 3.5	3.5
WellCare	WellCare Medicare Rx Saver (PDP) 3.5	3.5
UnitedHealthcare	AARP MedicareRx Walgreens (PDP) 3.5	3.5
Cigna	Cigna Secure Rx (PDP) 3.5	3.5
Cigna	Cigna Secure-Essential Rx (PDP) 3.5	3.5
WellCare	WellCare Medicare Rx Select (PDP) 3.5	3.5

Bottom Tier - Below Average Plans

Insurance Carrier	Plan Name / Quality Rating	Quality Rating
Florida Blue	BlueMedicare Premier Rx (PDP) 3.0	3.0
Florida Blue	BlueMedicare Complete Rx (PDP) 3.0	3.0
Mutual of Omaha Rx	Mutual of Omaha Rx Premier (PDP) 2.5	2.5
Mutual of Omaha Rx	Mutual of Omaha Rx Plus (PDP) 2.5	2.5

New Plans Without Star Ratings

Insurance Carrier	Plan Name / Quality Rating	Quality Rating
Clear Spring Health	Clear Spring Health Premier Rx (PDP) No Rating	No Rating
Clear Spring Health	Clear Spring Health Value Rx (PDP) No Rating	No Rating